Sorry I couldn't not say something

Replied by adamelphick on topic Sorry I couldn't not say something

Posted 14 years 8 months ago #10108

CJJ;10092 wrote: http://www.the-t-bar.com/showthread.php?t=391&highlight=google

Can I just say that while the sentiments are understandable, be careful not to make this look like a T-bar versus mg-rover vendetta.

It is a sore point for Kara, but the last thing she wants, or any of us want, is an all out war.

No-one is going to stop any one saying what they want, within reason, but we don't want a situation where we create a tit-for-tat slanging match.

It is innevitable that members and staff from the mg-rover forum will read these posts, most of us are a member of both.

I know that a lot of us would like to see a bit more acceptance, and while I think it is fair to say that Kara isn't interested in being welcomed back with open arms, it would be nice if the forums could run alongside each other without any animosity toward each other. This can only benifit the MGF/TF community as a whole, whereas an outright war may damage it.

My comments on the other forum are purely to try to improve it as I like both.


Exactly why I asked the question 'is it ok to mention us now' .... no answer forthcoming as usual. Shall I pvt Steve in my capacity as 'PR Person' and officially ask to clear the air?

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • cjj
  • Offline
  • Administrator
  • Administrator
  • The future is vented.
  • Posts: 6411
  • Thanks: 1330

Replied by cjj on topic Sorry I couldn't not say something

Posted 14 years 8 months ago #10109

AdamElphick;10108 wrote: Exactly why I asked the question 'is it ok to mention us now' .... no answer forthcoming as usual. Shall I pvt Steve in my capacity as 'PR Person' and officially ask to clear the air?


I think if you are going to ask the question then it would be courtesy to ask him directly, however, I would wait until Kara is back and see if it is OK with her first.
by cjj

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Replied by adamelphick on topic Sorry I couldn't not say something

Posted 14 years 8 months ago #10110

CJJ;10109 wrote: I think if you are going to ask the question then it would be courtesy to ask him directly, however, I would wait until Kara is back and see if it is OK with her first.


OK I will wait for Kara to come back - however I think it should be personal choice for any of us here or there if we want to mention ANYTHING on either forum to be honest. The them and us that has happened due to the ban (which I think was very unfair and childish but nonetheless happened) is very silly.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • cjj
  • Offline
  • Administrator
  • Administrator
  • The future is vented.
  • Posts: 6411
  • Thanks: 1330

Replied by cjj on topic Sorry I couldn't not say something

Posted 14 years 8 months ago #10114

AdamElphick;10110 wrote: OK I will wait for Kara to come back - however I think it should be personal choice for any of us here or there if we want to mention ANYTHING on either forum to be honest. The them and us that has happened due to the ban (which I think was very unfair and childish but nonetheless happened) is very silly.


You are right, we should all be able to speak as individuals, but I was refering to asking the question as a member of the T-bar rather than an individual.
by cjj

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Replied by adamelphick on topic Sorry I couldn't not say something

Posted 14 years 8 months ago #10117

CJJ;10114 wrote: You are right, we should all be able to speak as individuals, but I was refering to asking the question as a member of the T-bar rather than an individual.


Ah OK get you - yea we can discuss what united front we take to Steve as a forum if that is what is wanted.... I certainly don't mind doing the pvt to him once we decide.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • gos
  • Offline
  • Qualified MGer
  • Qualified MGer
  • X Black Beauty X
  • Posts: 626
  • Thanks: 8

Replied by gos on topic Sorry I couldn't not say something

Posted 14 years 8 months ago #10119

jonnocash;10094 wrote: hear hear :grouphug:



double hear hear :)
by gos

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • bacchus
  • Offline
  • Qualified MGer
  • Qualified MGer
  • Food, Photography & Little British Sports Cars
  • Posts: 991
  • Thanks: 237

Replied by bacchus on topic Sorry I couldn't not say something

Posted 14 years 8 months ago #10120

Gos;10119 wrote: double hear hear :)


Totally agree as well, we need to be above any sniping, Kara sure is and we need to follow her lead. After all its all about the Marque, which ever side of the fence you sit or like many of us right in the middle with the barbed wire right up your bum crack.....lol

Craig
by bacchus

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Replied by Adam-Mgtf on topic Sorry I couldn't not say something

Posted 14 years 8 months ago #10167
lmao i take total credit for instigating that little mess and accept non of the blame for the resulting chaos :D

at least were all heading towards being able to talk openly on .org

Teesside meet, open to all MG/Rs. 3rd Sunday of the month, ask for times and places!!!
"There's something about engines that calms me down"

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Replied by le500 on topic Sorry I couldn't not say something

Posted 14 years 8 months ago #10285
OK could someone PM me with what exactly happened as I'm a bit slow

Too much non-technical stuff on .orf f/tf forum
Mods come down hard on perpetrators
Kara starts this forum as a consequence
Kara messages other members to come to her forum instead
Someone complains
Kara is banned
F/TF forum reverts to non-technical stuff anyway
.org regulars post on here as well as there
the ill feeling rears its head in the google rankings thread

Is that about right? I've also asked someone at .org for the official version of events, would be interesting to compare.

Kara didn't mention any of it at the lewes meet... although I am very deaf. And I think I am getting quite confused as well.
by le500

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Replied by Adam-Mgtf on topic Sorry I couldn't not say something

Posted 14 years 8 months ago #10311

le500;10285 wrote: although I am very deaf. And I think I am getting quite confused as well.


what did you say? where am i :dunno:

Teesside meet, open to all MG/Rs. 3rd Sunday of the month, ask for times and places!!!
"There's something about engines that calms me down"

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Replied by andycolm on topic Sorry I couldn't not say something

Posted 14 years 8 months ago #10315
Thats pretty much it.
Mind, if you think thats bad you try talking about being a MacDroitwich member on there and see what happens :whistle:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.527 seconds