mgf or tf

Hi everyone , i am new to the site and i want to know which is the best an mgf or tf as i want to buy one for my wife as she likes them. Many thanks p38 {Don]

p38 wrote: Hi everyone , i am new to the site and i want to know which is the best an mgf or tf as i want to buy one for my wife as she likes them. Many thanks p38 {Don]

Haha, that is a can of worms you're looking at there.
Both MGF and MGTF have their fans, some like both equally.:shrug:

If we knew your idea of how much you want to spend, might point you one way or another. :yesnod:
Obviously the TF is newer than the F, but early TFs had a very harsh ride. The F comes in three engine outputs 120, 143, and 160 bhp.(all 1.8l)
Also the TF comes in different engine sizes 1.6 and 1.8litre. The 1.6 is 115, the 1.8 comes in 135 or 160bhp.

There is also an automatic version of both.
ps.:welcome2:

I agree with David! Depends how much you want to spend. I picked up a decent MGF including hard top for 1400. Needs some tlc, but pretty good. Whereas if you had 5 or 10 thousabd to spend you could find something immaculate of either type, and 15 would get you a (practically) new TF.

Ps: prices above are wild guestimates other than the 1400, but it gives you something to think about.

I have a mgtf which i bought 1 year ago,and when i was in the market for buying i did not know which to buy as i think the mgf looks pretttier but i like the suspension set up on the tf better.Thats what made me buy the tf but i think the mgf can be bought at bargin prices its up to you?

Both equally brilliant cars - choice will come down to personal preference.
Interestingly, because of the silly way the gov. works out how much we pay on vehicle tax the 'F' 1.8 will save you a £30 quid a year over the standard TF 1.8. :silly:

Also depends how badly the dark side pulls you in... :evil: Cars before 2001 (?) can have a sportier cat fitted and still pass the MOT. I'm fighting the urge so far! :woohoo:

Welcome P38 (and Dave101). Whichever way you go, this forum is a wealth of good information and friendly advice. My suggestion would be to go see a few, test drive, or let the wife choose her own poison. There's plenty for sale right now and some great bargains to be had.

My daughter had an mgf 1.8i vvc which was very fast, lots went wrong but that's not to say they all go wrong. I now have a mgtf 1.8 120 stepspeed (semi auto gearbox) which my wife loves to bits because it's so easy to drive, especially in traffic and on hills. I've only had it for 3 weeks or so myself. Still thrilled with it.

dave101 wrote: I have a mgtf which i bought 1 year ago,and when i was in the market for buying i did not know which to buy as i think the mgf looks pretttier but i like the suspension set up on the tf better.Thats what made me buy the tf but i think the mgf can be bought at bargin prices its up to you?

:welcome2:

Welcome to the forum!
As the lads said they are both equally good cars. both of which have great features.
The best thing is to look for a car in superb shape that has had it's major (expensive) maintenance items done recently (Timing belt, Head gasket), and is free of rust with excellent paint, interior and hood. Even first class cars can be bought for silly prices.
Good luck with the hunt. You are in for some fun!

Also check this buyer's guide :yesnod:

I always think the choice comes down to looks and performance.

If you like the look of an F then the F is for you, likewise, if you like the look of the TF then the TF is for you.

The TF is a more "sportier" ride than the F in general. I think Harsh is a harsh word to use, as it is a matter of taste. I know that I am not the only one who prefers the more go-cart like handling of the TF, especially in the twisties. I know people who have moved to the TF from an F and prefer the TF handling, but it is all down to personal taste.

The only real test is to drive a few models and compare them. Only you can tell which is best for you.

I know my TF is fitted with softer suspension but the handling and ride are so much better than on my MGF