Which song version is better?

I've listened to two versions of this song and I just can't decide which is better!

On the one hand you can't beat an original but on the cover they really vamped it up and Muse are excellent.

What do you guys think?

Original:

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h8tuTSi6Sck]YouTube - Nina Simone/ Feeling Good[/ame]

Muse cover:

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=inW91qRDGwI]YouTube - muse - feeling good[/ame]

Muse, without question IMO

Here's a tricky one:

Ramones:

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wMD7Ezp3gWc]YouTube - The Ramones - I wanna be sedated[/ame]

Offspring:

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_A7I7cq72qg]YouTube - The Offspring - I Wanna Be Sedated[/ame]

Yves Adele Harlow;662 wrote: I've listened to two versions of this song and I just can't decide which is better!

On the one hand you can't beat an original but on the cover they really vamped it up and Muse are excellent.

Muse for me too.

Ramones, deffinitely.

Now mine.

Rihanna


[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uHlgAIwWDtg]YouTube - Umbrella - Rihanna (HQ) (Official Music Video)[/ame]


Or

The chipmunks?

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AUcpckyzGn8]YouTube - Rihanna- Umbrella (Chipmunk Version) Music Video[/ame]

I'm going with Muse and Offspring

Doubt that's much help though :rolleyes2:

Yves Adele Harlow;662 wrote: I've listened to two versions of this song and I just can't decide which is better!

On the one hand you can't beat an original but on the cover they really vamped it up and Muse are excellent.

What do you guys think?

Original:

YouTube - Nina Simone/ Feeling Good

Muse cover:

YouTube - muse - feeling good

muse may be the call of the young and trendy but nina simones does it for me just listen to her voice i still get shivers every time i hear her sing. ninas greatest is high on my cars play list

CJJ;666 wrote:
Now mine.

Rihanna

Or

The chipmunks?

Oooo... Or how about JLS :hehe:

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l8sCAAVBiEk]YouTube - JLS 'Umbrella' (STUDIO VERSION)[/ame]

jonnocash;877 wrote: muse may be the call of the young and trendy but nina simones does it for me just listen to her voice i still get shivers every time i hear her sing. ninas greatest is high on my cars play list

Well I'm glad Nina got someone's vote! She has an incredible voice doesn't she?

I really like Muse's vamped up version as I think the song actually lends itself to that rocky feel but Nina's voice just grabs you.

Fast Jan;918 wrote: Oooo... Or how about JLS :hehe:

YouTube - JLS 'Umbrella' (STUDIO VERSION)

Ok I know I'm about to lose all my self respect but I actually really like Rhianna's 'Umbrella'. And Jay Z is rather nice to. There I said it. :outtahere:

Yves Adele Harlow;961 wrote: Ok I know I'm about to lose all my self respect but I actually really like Rhianna's 'Umbrella'. And Jay Z is rather nice to. There I said it. :outtahere:

If you lose all self respect for liking Rhianna... how low am I sinking if I admit to liking JLS :rolleyes2: :shake:

Who are JLS?

Fast Jan;1102 wrote: If you lose all self respect for liking Rhianna... how low am I sinking if I admit to liking JLS :rolleyes2: :shake:

Oh dear.... I don't really know what to say... "my deepest condolances" :quote: :hehe: