SS underfloor pipes failure
- David Aiketgate
- Offline
- David
- mgf mk2 freestyle mpi 16" wheels, in Anthracite.
- Posts: 20331
- Thanks: 4437
Replied by David Aiketgate on topic Re: Aw: Re: SS underfloor pipes failure
Posted 13 years 5 months ago #24671David
:shrug:
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- gotenks1321
- Offline Topic Author
- Time served MGer
- Posts: 227
- Thanks: 15
Replied by gotenks1321 on topic Re: Aw: Re: SS underfloor pipes failure
Posted 13 years 5 months ago #24672Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Replied by petevick on topic Re: Aw: Re: SS underfloor pipes failure
Posted 13 years 5 months ago #24675not really, the whole lot corrodes, well at least mine had done.gotenks1321 wrote: .....Am I right in saying that's it's quite a common problem for the mild steel pipes to fail around the mounting points?
Pete Vickerstaff
MG F/TF Central
- your one stop shop for MGF/TF tips, tricks, faq's, how to's and links
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- David Aiketgate
- Offline
- David
- mgf mk2 freestyle mpi 16" wheels, in Anthracite.
- Posts: 20331
- Thanks: 4437
Replied by David Aiketgate on topic Re: Aw: Re: SS underfloor pipes failure
Posted 13 years 5 months ago #24676petevick wrote:
not really, the whole lot corrodes, well at least mine had done.gotenks1321 wrote: .....Am I right in saying that's it's quite a common problem for the mild steel pipes to fail around the mounting points?
Yeah, mine went all along the pipe and not at the brackets. :yesnod:
David
:shrug:
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- a Guest
- Visitor
- Thanks: 0
Replied by a Guest on topic Re: Aw: Re: SS underfloor pipes failure
Posted 13 years 5 months ago #24679Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- bryan young
- Offline
- Master MGer
- Posts: 3631
- Thanks: 773
gotenks1321 wrote: Bought them in October '08 from MGOC so I doubt it unfortunately :lol: The fact that the putty has now cured and I'm off out to fit them again might cause some issues with a claim too
Been thinking about the possibility of just replacing them with a length of silicon piping with suitably space brackets to hold it all secure and protect it. Stronger than rubber and more flexible than the steel ones, will have to price it up and see :thumbsup:
The MGOC would like to know of your problems with the leaks on their SS underfloor pipes, being stainless they should not have failed!!! " not fit for purpose" is the legal term ~ it is worth a call , speak to Chris Bentley :thumbsup:
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- gotenks1321
- Offline Topic Author
- Time served MGer
- Posts: 227
- Thanks: 15
bryan young wrote:
gotenks1321 wrote: Bought them in October '08 from MGOC so I doubt it unfortunately :lol: The fact that the putty has now cured and I'm off out to fit them again might cause some issues with a claim too
Been thinking about the possibility of just replacing them with a length of silicon piping with suitably space brackets to hold it all secure and protect it. Stronger than rubber and more flexible than the steel ones, will have to price it up and see :thumbsup:
The MGOC would like to know of your problems with the leaks on their SS underfloor pipes, being stainless they should not have failed!!! " not fit for purpose" is the legal term ~ it is worth a call , speak to Chris Bentley :thumbsup:
Unfortunately they have now been cut up and "repaired". I had to get the car running again so had no choice.
Looking at the bracket I cut out, the weld on the side that leaks look quite a bit different. I'll get it cleaned up and grab a pic when I get a chance, meanwhile, it's off to pay the tax man his six-monthly wage :pinch:
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- a Guest
- Visitor
- Thanks: 0
- David Aiketgate
- Offline
- David
- mgf mk2 freestyle mpi 16" wheels, in Anthracite.
- Posts: 20331
- Thanks: 4437
Replied by David Aiketgate on topic Re: SS underfloor pipes failure
Posted 13 years 5 months ago #24795David
:shrug:
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- a Guest
- Visitor
- Thanks: 0
David Aiketgate wrote: That's ice damage, imo. :yesnod:
Must be poor coolant mixture, as I have had mild steel pipes in long cold very subzero temps and never seen that.
Always check your coolant mixture folks!
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- bryan young
- Offline
- Master MGer
- Posts: 3631
- Thanks: 773
David Aiketgate wrote: That's ice damage, imo. :yesnod:
Yes that split is classic result of the pipe freezing, seen it many times on copper tube and the "burst" is exactly like this :ohmy: the rest of the pipes lok knackered anyway.
Will be very interested to see the photo from gotenks showing the failed bracket :shrug:
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.